The Method

The four studies compiled here are of an iconological nature. At present, however, the term iconology should be clarified. After more than fifty years of academic success, during which Panofsky’s iconological method gained acceptance as a scientific paradigm, iconology has reached a point where its premises and objectives are once more the subject of debate.

A major criticism, which was already voiced at an early stage, has been directed at Panofky’s iconographical analysis with its limited focus on the content of a work of art and its lack of concern for form or style. To quote Panofsky: ‘Iconography is the branch of art history concerned with the subject matter or meaning of works of art, as opposed to their form.’

While acknowledging the achievements of iconological research, critics have sought primarily to deal with the presumptions of Panofskian iconology by pointing out its limitations. JVJany iconologists are unaware of these limitations, however, as they consider the meaning of a work of art to be its iconographical or literary’ content. However, if we regard the subject matter as the content, then we are implicitly referring to something external to the
representation itself. But the iconologist might argue that iconographical analysis is merely a transitional phase on the way to a deeper and more comprehensive iconological interpretation. That interpretation deals with the intrinsic meaning, or what Panofsky called the ‘Dolmmentsinn’ or ‘Wesenssinn’ of a work of art.

Apart from the fact that Panofsky’s concept of phased system of meaning (pre-iconographical – iconographical – iconological) is untenable, it may be argued that the more profound iconological meaning, like the pre-iconographical and iconographical analyses, also refers to something external: culture and a general view of the world or ‘Weltanschauung,’ which constitutes the deeper meaning of a work of art. Johan Vanbergen, one of Panofsky’s more recent critics, draws the inevitable conclusion that the deeper meaning offered by the iconological method contributes to our knowledge of culture rather than to our understanding of the artistic phenomenon.

Consequently, if the methodology of the study of art history were based exclusively on iconographical and iconological analysis on the one hand, and purely formal-stylistic categories on the other, art history would be a study of the undifferentiated conceptual world of a culture, ignoring the history of specifically artistic phenomena and the complex structure of their development. According to Vanbergen, the key question in art-historical interpretation should be whether a representation manages to express a specific meaning beyond the illustrative significance derived from texts.

The real criticism, therefore, is leveled not so much at the iconographical and iconological analysis per se as at its status as the ultimate goal of art-historical interpretation.